All research
Consultation response··Updated ·6 min read·Digital ID·UK Policy·Civil Liberties

UK Digital ID: Ten Safeguards Parliament Must Legislate

Our response to the Cabinet Office consultation on digital identity (CP 1498): support in principle, with ten safeguards we want in primary legislation.

Update, November 2026: in July 2026 the incoming Prime Minister said the national digital ID scheme would be scrapped (BBC News, 18 July 2026). The House of Commons Library briefing Digital ID in the UK tracks the current position. This article records what we argued in May 2026. We think the same safeguards should apply to any later proposal.

On 5 May 2026 we submitted a response to the Cabinet Office consultation Making public services work for you with your digital identity (CP 1498), which ran from 10 March to 5 May 2026. This is a condensed version of the argument.

Our position was support in principle, opposition to the design as proposed. The EU’s eIDAS 2.0 regulation and Australia’s Digital ID Act 2024 show that a digital identity scheme can be given privacy limits in statute. The UK proposal, as consulted on, did not have them.

The convergence problem

The consultation paper says the digital ID would build on existing government infrastructure, including the passport service. At the same time, the Home Office was consulting on police use of facial recognition, including whether police should be able to search other government databases, such as passport and immigration records. The two consultations concerned the same records.

Without a statutory firewall, checking someone’s identity for a council form and running a police biometric search could draw on the same database. We think this is the most important fact in the debate.

Why “voluntary” is not enough

The government said digital ID would be voluntary. That was policy, not law, and policy can change with the government.

Identity checks tend to spread once the infrastructure exists. Companies House identity verification became a legal requirement for directors and people with significant control on 18 November 2025. Companies House estimated that 6 to 7 million people would need to verify by mid-November 2026.

Public reaction to the Online Safety Act’s age checks is also relevant. Proton VPN told TechRadar that hourly UK sign-ups rose by more than 1,400% when the checks began on 25 July 2025. A petition to repeal the Online Safety Act closed with 550,136 signatures. A separate petition, Do not introduce Digital ID cards, closed with 2,984,191.

Ten demands in primary legislation

Anything short of statute can be reversed by a minister. We asked for ten safeguards in primary legislation:

  1. Statutory non-mandation. A right not to use the system, with enforceable remedies. Section 74 of Australia’s Digital ID Act 2024 (“Creating and using a digital ID is voluntary”) is a model.
  2. A statutory firewall against police facial-recognition access. No identity database may be used to train, seed or query a facial recognition system without specific judicial pre-authorisation under PACE thresholds.
  3. Decentralised architecture by design. W3C Verifiable Credentials, decentralised identifiers, zero-knowledge proofs and selective disclosure as the default. No central wallet and no central ledger of transactions.
  4. Purpose limitation and anti-aggregation in statute. A relying party receives only the attributes it strictly needs. Linking across contexts is prohibited without specific consent.
  5. Right-to-work check redesign. The employer receives a yes or no answer (“this person has the right to work”), delivered by zero-knowledge proof, and no underlying immigration data. Employers get a good-faith reliance defence.
  6. Children’s data. Minimum age 16 for unsupervised use. No under-13s. A school-issued sandbox for ages 13 to 15, ending at 16.
  7. An independent statutory Digital Identity Commissioner. Appointed by a process modelled on the Judicial Appointments Commission, with power to pre-authorise new use cases and a two-year cooling-off period before commercial roles.
  8. Mandatory privacy-by-design technical controls. On-device biometric matching, hardware-backed keys, encryption at rest by default, third-party audit and published assurance.
  9. A statutory redress framework. When the system gets something wrong, people need a time-limited route to correction and compensation.
  10. A five-year sunset clause. The legislation lapses unless Parliament renews it.

What the architecture should look like

The techniques needed are set out in open standards and published research:

  • Zero-knowledge proofs for proving an attribute without disclosing the underlying data
  • Selective disclosure (SD-JWT VC) for verifiable credentials
  • BBS signatures for unlinkable presentation
  • On-device biometric matching with hardware-backed keys
  • Decentralised identifiers (W3C DIDs) for portable identity
  • Secure multi-party computation for verification across organisations
  • Differential privacy for any aggregate analytics

We suggested the Office for Digital Identities and Attributes (OfDIA) as the institutional home, with a wider remit and statutory independence. OfDIA already oversees digital verification services under Part 2 of the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 (OfDIA annual report, 2026).

The vendor question

Any digital identity system will be built by suppliers. NIST’s 2019 study of demographic effects in face recognition found that false positive rates differed between demographic groups in many, but not all, of the algorithms it tested (NISTIR 8280). Vendor selection should not be left to procurement alone. Statutory criteria, including limits on demographic error differences and support for zero-knowledge proofs, should constrain it.

What we asked for

We did not ask for a moratorium, and we do not oppose digital public services. We asked for a statutory framework that uses the privacy techniques available and takes the history of identity systems seriously.


The full submission was filed with the Cabinet Office on 5 May 2026. Cosmo Codex is the trading name of CosmoCodex Ltd.

Sources

  1. Cabinet Office, Making public services work for you with your digital identity (CP 1498), March 2026.
  2. Home Office, Legal framework for using facial recognition in law enforcement, consultation, December 2025.
  3. Companies House, Companies House confirms identity verification rollout from 18 November 2025, 5 August 2025.
  4. TechRadar, VPN demand skyrockets in the UK as age verification checks are enforced, July 2025.
  5. UK Parliament petitions 722903 (Repeal the Online Safety Act) and 730194 (Do not introduce Digital ID cards). Final signature counts.
  6. Australia, Digital ID Act 2024, section 74.
  7. Regulation (EU) 2024/1183 (eIDAS 2.0).
  8. OfDIA, 2026 annual report on the operation of Part 2 of the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025.
  9. NIST, Face Recognition Vendor Test Part 3: Demographic Effects (NISTIR 8280), December 2019.
  10. BBC News, Burnham to scrap digital ID to focus on ‘helping with cost of living’, 18 July 2026.
  11. House of Commons Library, Digital ID in the UK (CBP-10369).

Interested in working with us?

Get in touch to discuss our products, partnerships, or research collaborations.