Benchmark · v0.1 preview
VPN Privacy Benchmark.
An evidence-graded comparison of VPN providers on 28 criteria, with each evidence record rated by the Evidence Quality Score (EQS). TheVPNMatrix is funded by affiliate commission, which it discloses.
What this is — and isn't
v0.1 is a preview cut — 10 providers, publicly verifiable facts only (jurisdiction, audit auditor and year, court-tested incidents). It is intentionally narrow.
v0.2 will be the full dataset — 38 providers, all 28 criteria with EQS component scores, published as a versioned CSV/JSON on GitHub alongside an arXiv preprint of the methodology paper. Subscribe via contact for the release notice.
Per-record evidence lives on TheVPNMatrix, which renders the underlying records with their EQS components. This page is the academic-framing index; TheVPNMatrix is the operational database.
Benchmark · v0.1
Selected providers, publicly verifiable facts.
| Provider | Jurisdiction | Latest audit | Court-tested | Notes | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
CyberGhost | Romania | Deloitte · 2022 No-logs policy | None public | Owned by Kape Technologies since 2017, quarterly transparency reports | Records |
ExpressVPN | British Virgin Islands | KPMG · 2022 TrustedServer (RAM-only) infrastructure | Yes — 2017 Turkish authorities seized servers, no user data recovered | Acquired by Kape Technologies 2021 | Records |
IVPN | Gibraltar | Cure53 · 2022 Apps + backend | None public | Removed affiliate program 2022, transparency report quarterly | Records |
Mullvad | Sweden | Assured AB · 2023 Infrastructure | Yes — 2023 Swedish police raid yielded no user data (no-account model) | Accepts cash, no email required, RAM-only servers | Records |
NordVPN | Panama | PwC Switzerland · 2022 No-logs policy + infrastructure | Partial — 2018 Finland datacenter breach disclosed publicly in 2019 | Repeated independent audits since 2018 | Records |
Private Internet Access | United States | Deloitte · 2022 No-logs server configuration | Yes — 2016 FBI subpoena and 2017 grand jury produced no user data | Owned by Kape Technologies, source code public | Records |
ProtonVPN | Switzerland | Securitum · 2022 App + infrastructure | Limited — IP logging required only under Swiss court order with specific subject | Open-source apps across all platforms, transparency report | Records |
Surfshark | Netherlands | Deloitte · 2023 No-logs policy | None public | Re-incorporated from BVI to Netherlands 2021, merged with Nord Security 2022 | Records |
TunnelBear | Canada | Cure53 · 2023 Apps + backend (annual since 2016) | None public | Owned by McAfee since 2018, one of first VPNs to commit to annual public audits | Records |
Windscribe | Canada | No comprehensive public audit | Yes — 2022 Ukrainian server seizure produced no user data | Strong transparency reports, generous free tier | Records |
Listed alphabetically by provider · scoring bands held until v0.2 dataset import · all facts citable on TheVPNMatrix
How EQS works
Eight components, range −3 to 19.
The Evidence Quality Score (EQS) sums Type, Grade, Source Quality, Independence, Scope, Reproducibility, Age, and Conflict of Interest. The highest possible score is 19 and the lowest −3. Records stored today are scored on four of the eight components, so they score 0 to 13.
EQS = Type + Grade + SQS + Ind + Scp + Rep + Age + COI
Dataset roadmap
v0.2 — full dataset, GitHub-versioned, arXiv preprint.
38 providers · 28 criteria · 3,469 evidence records · open CSV/JSON with semantic versioning · CHANGELOG · methodology preprint on arXiv (cs.CR).
Notice of v0.2 dataset publication goes out via the Substack
